Early baseball off-season trading?

I think you should make this trade. Your pitchers are not that great, no offense, and Verlander will help you strengthen it a lot more. You already have a good shortstop with speed almost as good as Reyes, but you really are missing an ace on your team. Of course, you can get a decent pitcher without giving up Reyes, but I recommend getting a great pitcher and giving up someone you don't need as much. If you really want to, you can accept the trade for Lilly too, so you can boost your pitchers even more.